Smartphones in K-12 Schools: The Balancing Act

A Staples Business® Expert Solutions Guide.


In today’s fast-changing education landscape, smartphones in K-12 classrooms present a complex challenge for school administrators. These devices offer instant access to educational resources but also bring distractions and other issues.

Striking the right balance is no easy task.

The good news? With thoughtful strategies, your school can harness technology’s benefits while reducing its risks.

In this comprehensive article on K-12 school smartphone policies, we’ll break down the key issues, explore some possible solutions, and attempt to add some useful points-of-view on this often-heated debate.

The smartphone says Ding!: Students admit to checking their phones due to notifications (pickups) 13 times during school hours every day.

What’s the Big Deal with Students and Phones in School?

The rise in personal smartphone ownership among students has fundamentally reshaped classroom dynamics, and we’ve got the numbers to prove it. In a recent survey1 of students aged 11 - 17:

  • 97% reported using their phones during school hours
    • With a median of 43 minutes per day.
  • They reported a median of 237 notifications per day.
    • Nearly a quarter (23%) of those notifications were received during school hours.
    • Of those 54 notifications they received during school hours, they checked their phone (known as a ‘pickup’) 13 times.
  • 32% of in-school phone usage was spent on social media.
    • 26% on video streaming, like YouTube
    • 17% on gaming

Numerous perspectives abound on the topic, so let’s first try to unravel the most prevalent of them:

The problem with cell phones in schools: 97% of students admit to their phones during school hours. Median time: 43 minutes each day.